We put safety at the core of our business
New York (NY) applies sales tax to precious metals purchases below $1,000 but provides an exemption for qualifying bullion transactions above that threshold. The exemption, in place since 1989 under Tax Law § 1115(a)(27), was successfully preserved in the last state budget.
Federal taxation rules apply when precious metals are sold at a profit, and New York taxes capital gains as part of state income tax at rates among the highest in the country.
Precious metals such as gold and silver are classified as collectibles under U.S. federal tax law. Profits realized when selling investment metals may therefore be subject to federal capital gains tax, with a maximum rate of 28%, depending on income level and holding period.
Capital gains tax generally applies when metals are sold for fiat currency or exchanged for goods and services. No tax is due simply for purchasing or holding bullion.
New York's progressive income tax for 2025 ranges from 4% to 10.9% across nine brackets. New York does not distinguish between short-term and long-term capital gains — all gains are taxed as ordinary income at the same progressive rates regardless of holding period. Residents of New York City pay an additional local income tax of 3.078% to 3.876% depending on income, resulting in a combined state and city rate of up to approximately 14.7% on capital gains before federal taxes.
New York provides a sales tax exemption for qualifying precious metals under Tax Law § 1115(a)(27) when the total transaction value exceeds $1,000. This exemption covers state and local sales taxes.
The exemption applies to investment-grade gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, and iridium — provided the receipt depends only on the value of the metal content, and where applicable, the retailer is registered with the New York Department of State under General Business Law § 359-e.
Premium rules for coins: New York applies additional tests for coins to determine whether they qualify as investment bullion or collectibles. For silver coins, the exemption does not apply if the sale price is 140% or more of the silver metal value. For gold coins of 1/4 oz or less, the threshold is 120%; for larger gold coins, 115%. For platinum and palladium coins, the threshold is also 115%. Coins that exceed these premiums are considered collectibles and are fully taxable regardless of transaction size.
Excluded items include:
Purchases below $1,000 are subject to the statewide sales tax rate of 4%, plus applicable local taxes. Combined rates can reach approximately 8.875% in New York City.
New York offers a partial tax advantage through the $1,000 sales tax exemption for qualifying bullion, but this exemption has unique complexity: coin eligibility depends on premium-over-spot ratios, and South African coins are categorically excluded. The exemption has also faced repeated legislative threats and remains at risk.
On the capital gains side, New York is one of the least favorable states in the country, with rates reaching 10.9% — and up to 14.7% combined for NYC residents — with no preferential treatment for long-term gains.